Give Your Mayo a Makeover

Give Your Mayo a Makeover

Step up your sauce game with these mix-in ideas for everyday condiments.


When the same old standby condiments just can’t cut the mustard – yes, pun entirely intended – it’s time to mix things up. See how just a few add-ins can make all the difference to 5 common condiments at your next barbecue or picnic.

Madeover Mayonnaise
Mayo is perfect as a blank slate for a multitude of mix-ins. Think bright, aromatic flavors to cut through the heavy base.

  • Pesto: Blend 2 tablespoons of pesto into a cup of mayonnaise for delicious, Italian-style flavor. It’s yummy on your average turkey sandwich, or as a spread for tomato and mozzarella on foccacia.
  • Lemon Juice and Sea Salt: Create bright, clean flavor when you squeeze a quarter of a lemon into a cup of mayonnaise, plus a dash of sea salt. We love it on white fish or as a dip for French fries!


Tip:
To prevent the citrus seeds from falling into your mixture, hold your lemon skin-side down as you squeeze.

  • Garlic: Spice up your next cookout by serving garlic mayonnaise in an old-fashioned squirt bottle alongside your burgers and grilled chicken sandwiches. A teaspoon of minced garlic is all you need for 1 cup of mayonnaise.


Kicked-up Ketchup
Bold, sweet and slightly acidic, ketchup can stand up to stronger mix-ins.

  • Curry: It’s a strong, savory herb, so use it sparingly – just a pinch will add exotic layers of flavor to 1 cup of tomato ketchup.
  • Barbecue Sauce: Combine two classics and create a new condiment favorite! Whether you have a cup left or an entire bottle, mix ketchup with equal parts barbecue sauce and enjoy.


Mightier Mustard
Tart and vinegary, mustard is great on almost anything. But add a little bit of sweetness or some aromatic herbs and you’ll dress up this simple staple.

  • Rosemary: Like mustard, rosemary has a slightly bitter, aromatic quality, making the two perfect mates. For a gourmet sandwich spread, add 1 teaspoon chopped rosemary to 1/2 cup Dijon mustard.
Registration

Become a member of P&G everyday and get exclusive offers!

Become a member


Tip:
Don’t bother plucking each rosemary sprig off its stem – instead, gently pinch your fingers and pull backward down the steam to easily remove them.

  • Applesauce: For Dijon or coarse-grain mustard, try mixing in a few spoonsful of cinnamon applesauce. The unlikely ingredients combine to create a sweet, tangy sauce that’s delicious on pork and chicken.
  • Cranberry: The sweet and savory combination – along with the tartness – is perfect for pork or chicken dishes.


Tip:
Discover 5 other ways to spice up your mustard with our simple ideas.

Better Butter
You may not think of butter as a condiment, but it’s the perfect vehicle for adding flavor, especially when you mix in a bit of sweetness.

  • Berries: Drop a few berries into softened butter, and then mash together. We love blueberry butter on a whole grain bagel or blackberry butter on toast.
  • Honey: A few drops of honey can give butter a whole new attitude – just wait until you melt it on fresh-baked bread.

Tip:
Looking for more ways to embellish butter? Check out our 7 flavored butter recipes.


Power Sour Cream
A true chameleon, sour cream does everything from topping potatoes to keeping cakes moist. Add a bit of flavor and you’re really onto something.

  • Cilantro: This fresh, leafy herb has bold, distinct flavor, so stir just 1/2 teaspoon chopped cilantro into a cup of sour cream to instantly dress up fajitas or a taco salad.
  • Chipotle Peppers: Look for canned chipotle peppers in adobo sauce at your local grocery – they have a spicy, smoky flavor, so finely chop the peppers and then add 1/8 teaspoon to a cup of sour cream. Yum!

With a little creativity, the secret really can be in the sauce. What’s your favorite way to add in extra flavor where it’s least expected? Let us know in the comments!

Complete your personal information

Please fill in the information marked with an asterisk to proceed; if you want to get tailored offers and content, don't forget to fill in the optional fields.

Hi Doris! We'd recommend low-fat plain Greek yogurt as a mayonnaise substitute. You can also try mashed avocado, hummus or low-fat cottage cheese. Best, Nicole, P&G everyday

  • Report it

Doris

Reported

My husband takes a blood thinner(WARFRIN) and is not allowed to use mayo, are thee any good subsitutes???

  • Report it
Janet

Janet

Reported

Love the mayo creations article

  • Report it